Week 5: Link vs. Princess Zelda[]
Winner! Link!!! 12 1/2 > 7 |
|||||
A battle between the Legendary Hero, Link and the Princess of Destiny, Zelda! | |||||
Votes for Link[]
Vidiman 22:27, 20 May 2008 (UTC):I think Link can win!After all, LINK has a sword, a sheild, some items, and some other stuff.Vidiman 22:27, 20 May 2008 (UTC) Anonymous votes[]
|
Votes for Princess Zelda[]
Anonymous votes[]
| ||||
Comments[]one has the sword of evils bane but can it really kill someone not evil?--Power courage wisdom and time 20:08, 14 May 2008 (UTC) Someone said that Link would win in a FIGHT! This is a popularity contest everyone! Read the rules! From an angry XXXXX 21:33, 14 May 2008 (UTC)
Come on guys! This is Link, the hero of the game verses a girl who he doesn't even have to save. Mr kmil |
Week 6: Hyrule vs. Termina[]
Winner! "Hyrule!!!" 17 1/2 > 9 |
|||||
Votes for Hyrule[]
Anonymous votes[]
|
Votes for Termina[]
Anonymous votes[]
| ||||
Comments[]Err, I don't know if you read this already HoT87, but it's a popularity contest. Whether or not Hyrule is more theologically, technologically or even logically sound than Termina is a moot point. You like it more? Say that instead. I'm not trying to be an asshole here or anything, but you're also confusing other members. I'm sorry, but to actually make people pay attention to the rules they must be enforced. --AuronKaizer 23:55, 21 May 2008 (UTC) Err, I don't know if you noticed AK, but popularity is based on countless things to individuals, and to me, it's based on favoritism, strength, character, and common sense. You may want to re-read the rules because they say, and I quote: "You may vote for your favorite or who you think would win in an competition between the two combatants that week." I try to stick to the general thought we all have of which would triumph if put up against it. So I think you need to reevaluate your idea of this contest because "popularity" is a vague thing, and many things go into it. Your idea of popularity is more closed than mine I'm afraid, I'm more open-minded. It's you that's confusing members by trying to strictly force them to choose based on favoritism alone. And I am not trying to be rude, but I don't think it's your place to try to tell someone how to choose their opinion. Hero of Time 87 00:48, 22 May 2008 (UTC) What happened to the suggest a fight part of the temple of courage user: solar flute Sorry, but Twilight Princess was one of the greatest to come since Ocarina of Time. Majora's Mask was a rip-off of Ocarina of Time, taking it apart and putting it back together with a weak plot. Definitely the weakest game in the series. Golden Power 22:17, 23 May 2008 (UTC)
Actually Twilight Princess has a lot of innovations and funnier puzzles than Ocarina of Time and the Majora's Mask changes you're talking about are just three horrible days that make you going back on time and losing all your itens.--Ganny321 I honestly agree, Ocarina and Twilight FAR outweigh Majora's Mask. Majora's Mask was really just a repetitious game that basically took Ocarina of Time apart and put the pieces back together a different way. Twilight was actually the most original game in a long time, whereas Majora's Mask was an obvious attempt to repeat Ocarina, hence all the identical charcters and appearances. It's a great game, don't get me wrong. It's just very far from being the best game of the series. Twilight was one of the best to come in my view as well since Ocarina of Time. There was nothing original about Majora's Mask, b/c it was Ocarina put together a different way, like Golden Power said. Hero of Time 87 00:28, 24 May 2008 (UTC) Yeah, you're way off on Majora being the "villain of villains." Almost everyone here reserves that place for Ganondorf I'm sure, and the characters are quite the opposite (weak repetitions of what they were in OOT). The three days gets old, and you always lose your items. If anything was a "weak attempt to reproduce OoT" it was Majora's Mask. Twilight Princess was the best game to come since OOT by far and wide. Golden Power 00:42, 24 May 2008 (UTC) i'm not saying Twilight Princess is worse than Majora's Mask but as far as orginality goes its just as guilty as Majora for copying OoT. The Dungeons and their order is a prime example. 1st dungeon inside a giant tree (Deku Tree), 2nd inside a active volcano (Fire temple), 3rd underneath a lake(water temple) need I mention it was drained when you got there. Hey forest, fire and water; well then have a master sword before you walk into a Wind Waker dungeon remake (Temple of the Gods), next enjoy the temple that combines the spirit and shadow temple together. I know zelda games tend to follow the same themes but all Twilight Pincess does is recreate the adult half of OoT. I agree there are several shared elements between Twilight Princess and Ocarina of Time (but honestly, which games don't), but you're wrong about it being completely a remake of it. The only shared thing I see between them is Forest, Fire and Water as you said. But beyond that, those other things don't really have much legitimacy. Majora's Mask was a BLATANT rip-off of Ocarina of Time. Twilight Priness had A LOT more originality to it than you give it credit for. And no, it's not equally guilty by any means. Majora's Mask was far more blatant, that's just being honest with ourselves. Hero of Time 87 04:53, 24 May 2008 (UTC)
Actually, Majora's Mask was a very blatant repeat of Ocarina of Time. Just look at it: the child and adult Malon, the reuse of the Adult Ruto, the reuse of Nabooru under a new name, the reuse of Twinrova as good witches this time, the list goes on. They literally took Ocarina apart and just put it back together again a different way to get Majora's Mask. That is an obvious reuse of Ocarina of Time. Twilight Princess was actually original in countless ways with minor references to Ocarina of Time, such as some of the temples and items. But a floating city in the clouds, a realm of twilight complete with a palace, the introduction of Snowpeak, etc. There was a lot more originality to Twilight Princess than Majora's Mask. As I said, let's be honest with ourselves. That's why it took less than 18 months to make Majora's Mask, because they already had its major pieces in Ocarina of Time. All they had to do was break it apart, put it back together a different way, make up some new names, and voila: Majora's Mask. Hero of Time 87 01:25, 27 May 2008 (UTC) It should be noted that the concept of a Twilight Realm is not original. It's a blatent rip off of the Dark World from Link to the Past. Demonic Knight 08:10, 27 may 2008 (UTC) No, it's different. The TR os:
Viola. XXXXX 18:09, 27 May 2008 (UTC) But in the same way, the Twilight Realm can be compared to the grim state of Hyrule in Adult Link's time in OOT, whereas MM has a different villain for starters, that has new depth and a twist from the traditional tale of Ganon. It's set in a parallel universe, so I think the reuse of characters is more of a quirk than anything. They've even reinvented them with different jobs, characteristics, etc. Of course the whole series follows the same basic outline, especially since they had to follow Ocarina of Time, not an easy task. Plus, Majora's Mask sees Link with the ability to turn Adult (Oni Link) AND morph into other species with the masks (also a brand new feature). Elements of music, transformations, time travel and just plain epicness. - Anon. |
Week 7: Agahnim vs. Zant[]
Winner! "Zant!!!" 6 1/2 < 21 |
|||||
Votes for Agahnim[]
Anonymous votes[]1: We all know Zant is going to win. Regardless, I like Agahnim better, since he's mentally stable ;) 2. well, agahnim was able to sacrifice all of the maidens and zelda. that has to count for something. In addition, he was able to do all this without the help of Ganon. He was even able to take out the king and take control of Hyrule. Before that, he stopped an entire war and brought peace to Hyrule. Anyone can start a war, but it takes a lot to actually stop a war. Zant was a nobody until Ganon came along anyway. 3. Agahnim... he's the original baddie under the baddie. I mean, Zant is cool and all - I, personally, hate his guts because he's lame, but that makes him a good villain - but Agahnim seemed to be a lot cooler. He pretty much took over Hyrule - that's a pretty accomplishment for an underling! |
Votes for Zant[]
Plus, I have to say his battle strategy was quite unique and well devised.~DekuBaily Anonymous votes[]
| ||||
Comments[]BAZALINK Zant would kick Aghanim's @##. Just look at them, Aghanim looks like an extra from Aladdin and Zant wears the helmet that looks like a devil frog!
This reminds me of a squash match. --AuronKaizer 12:58, 30 May 2008 (UTC) it's 3 < 17! End it! ~~ UberPhoeb 15:01, 31 May 2008 (UTC) we really need to make one where the popularity is equal. - solar flute |
Week 8: Aquamentus vs. Gleeok[]
Winner! Gleeok 6 < 16 |
|||||
Votes for Aquamentus[]
Anonymous votes[]
4. What the heck, he looks cooler |
Votes for Gleeok[]
Anonymous votes[]
| ||||
Comments[]
THE GREATEST BATTLE OF ALL TIME. IN THE HISTORY OF THIS SITE, AND ANY OTHER. AQUAMENTUS AND GLEEOK ARE THE GREATEST MONSTERS OF ALL TIME. AND IF I MAY CONTINUE TO GLOAT, I AM 7-0, ABOUT TO MAKE IT 8. I AM SORRY BUT I CAN'T VOTE FOR MY TWO FAVORITES OF ALL TIME. ALTHOUGH MY MONEY WOULD BE ON GLEEOK I FEEL AQUAMENTUS IS FAR MORE MEMORABLE. OVERALL: AQUAMENTUS WAS A PAIN IN THE ASS FOR ME IN THE ORACLE OF SEASONS, BUT GLEEOK IS FAR TOUGHER. WINNER: GLEEOK! Kperfekt722 19:49, 5 June 2008 (UTC)
Just so we're clear, is this about Gleeok in general or specifically the one from Phantom Hourglass? Xykeb Zraliv 17:14, 6 June 2008 (UTC) Doesn't Gleeok only appear in Phantom hourglass? I may be wrong though...DekuBaily Gleeok is in Legend of Zelda and Oracle of Seasons as well as phantom hourglass Yes, Gleeok appears in those games too, but that doesn't answer my original question. Are we talking about all Gleeoks or just the one in Phantom Hourglass? Xykeb Zraliv 02:15, 7 June 2008 (UTC) Well, you asked the question that we answered. And we're talking about all the Gleeoks. XXXXX Talk to me OR ELSE! 02:22, 7 June 2008 (UTC) What are you talking about? My question wasn't answered until you answered it just now....It was DekuBaily's question that got answered. Xykeb Zraliv 03:46, 7 June 2008 (UTC)
|